SOCIALSTUDIESHELP.COM

History of Labor Unions

History of Labor Unions

The Labor Union Movement in America

The roots of our country’s trade unions extend deep into the early history of America. Several of the Pilgrims arriving at Plymouth Rock in 1620 were working craftsmen. Captain John Smith, who led the ill-fated settlement in 1607 on Virginia’s James River, pleaded with his sponsors in London to send him more craftsmen and working people.

Primitive unions, or guilds, of carpenters and cordwainers, cabinet makers and cobblers made their appearance, often temporary, in various cities along the Atlantic seaboard of colonial America. Workers played a significant role in the struggle for independence; carpenters disguised as Mohawk Indians were the “host” group at the Boston Tea Party in 1773. The Continental Congress met in Carpenters Hall in Philadelphia, and there the Declaration of Independence was signed in 1776. In “pursuit of happiness” through shorter hours and higher pay, printers were the first to go on strike, in New York in 1794; cabinet makers struck in 1796; carpenters in Philadelphia in 1797; cordwainers in 1799. In the early years of the 19th century, recorded efforts by unions to improve the workers’ conditions, through either negotiation or strike action, became more frequent.

By the 1820s, various unions involved in the effort to reduce the working day from 12 to 10 hours began to show interest in the idea of federation-of joining together in pursuit of common objectives for working people.

As ineffective as these first efforts to organize may have been, they reflected the need of working people for economic and legal protection from exploiting employers. The invention of the steam engine and the growing use of water power to operate machinery were developing a trend toward a factory system not much different from that in England which produced misery and slums for decades. Starting in the 1830s and accelerating rapidly during the Civil War, the factory system accounted for an ever-growing share of American production. It also produced great wealth for a few, grinding poverty for many.

With workers recognizing the power of their employers, the number of local union organizations increased steadily during the mid-19th century. In a number of cities, unions in various trades joined together in citywide federations. The Nation Labor Union, (actually a federation– an organization of local unions) formed in 1866. The NLU eventually persuaded Congress to pass an eight hour day for Federal workers. Never very strong, it was a casualty of the sweeping economic depression of 1873.

Five years later, the Knights of Labor captured the public imagination. Formed in 1869 by Uriah Stephens and expanded rapidly under the leadership of Terrance Powdery, the Knights were an all-embracing organization committed to a cooperative society. Membership was open to all workers, whether they be skilled or unskilled, black or white, male or female. The Knights achieved a membership of nearly 750,000 during the next few years, but the skilled and unskilled workers who had joined the Knights in hope of improvement in their hours and wages found themselves fragmented by the rift between skilled and unskilled workers. Skilled workers tired of labor activity on the part of unskilled workers who were easily replaced. The Knights, an effective labor force, declined after the Haymarket Square riots. In the riot members of the Knights of Labor where accused of throwing a bomb which killed police officers. The Knights, already fragmented, where faced with enormous negative publicity, and eventually disbanded.

The American Federation of Labor was founded by Samuel Gompers in 1886. Gompers, born in 1850, came as a boy with his parents to America from the Jewish slums of London; he entered the cigar-making trade and received much of his education as a “reader” (a worker who read books, newspaper stories, poetry and magazine articles to fellow employees to help break the monotony of their work in the shop) and became a leader of his local union and of the national Cigar Makers Union.

A statement by the founders of the AFL expressed their belief in the need for more effective union organization. “The various trades have been affected by the introduction of machinery, the subdivision of labor, the use of women’s and children’s labor and the lack of an apprentice system-so that the skilled trades were rapidly sinking to the level of pauper labor,” the AFL declared. “To protect the skilled labor of America from being reduced to beggary and to sustain the standard of American workmanship and skill, the trades unions of America have been established.” Thus the AFL was a federation that organized only unions of skilled workers.

The strike illustrated the increasing tendency of the government to offer moral support and military force to break strikes. The injunction, issued usually and almost automatically by compliant judges on the request of government officials or corporations, became a prime legal weapon against union organizing and action.

A better method of federal intervention occurred during a 1902 strike of anthracite coal miners, under the banner of the United Mine Workers. More than 100,000 miners in northeastern Pennsylvania called a strike on May 12, and kept the mines closed all that summer. When the mine owners refused a UMW proposal for arbitration, President Theodore Roosevelt intervened on Oct. 3, and on Oct. 16 appointed a commission of mediation and arbitration. Five days later the miners returned to their jobs, and five months later the Presidential Commission awarded them a 10 percent wage increase and shorter work days-but not the formal union recognition they had sought.

In 1911 a fire broke out at the Triangle Shirtwaist Co. on New York’s lower east side. About 150 employees almost all of them young women-perished when the fire swept through the upper floors of the loft building in which they worked. Many burned to death; others jumped and died. Why so large a casualty list? The safety exits on the burning floors had been securely locked, allegedly to prevent “loss of goods.” New York and the country were aroused by the tragedy. A state factory investigation committee headed by Frances Perkins (she was to become Franklin Roosevelt’s secretary of labor in 1933, the first woman cabinet member in history) paved the way for many long needed reforms in industrial safety and fire prevention measures.

Another of the historic industrial conflicts prior to World War I occurred in 1912 in the textile mills of Lawrence, Mass. It was led not by an AFL union but by the radical Industrial Workers of the World-the IWW, or the Wobblies, as they were generally known -an organization in frequent verbal and physical conflict with the AFL and its affiliates. The strike in Lawrence started when the mill owners, responding to a state legislature action reducing the work week from 54 to 52, coldly and without prior notice cut the pay rates by a 31/2 percent. The move produced predictable results: a strike of 50,000 textile workers; arrests; fiery statements by the IWW leaders; police and militia attacks on peaceful meetings; and broad public support for the strikers. Some 400 children of strikers were “adopted” by sympathizers. When women strikers and their children were attacked at the railroad station by the police after authorities had decided no more youngsters could leave town, an enraged public protest finally forced the mill owners not only to restore the pay cuts but to increase the workers’ wages to more realistic levels.

Congress, at the urging of the AFL, created a separate U.S. Department of Labor with a legislative mandate to protect and extend the rights of wage earners. A Children’s Bureau, with a major concern to protect the victims of job exploitation, was created. The LaFollette Seaman’s Act required urgently needed improvements in the working conditions on ships of the U.S. merchant marine. Of crucial importance, the Clayton Act of 1914 made explicit the legal concept that “the labor of a human being is not a commodity or article of commerce” and hence not subject to the Sherman Act provisions which had been the legal basis for injunctions against union organization. Clayton gave legalized strikes and boycotts and peaceful picketing, and dramatically limited the use of injunctions in labor disputes. Little wonder that AFL President Gompers hailed the Clayton Act as a “magna carta.”

The “Roaring Twenties,” nostalgically depicted in some movies and musical comedies as an era of unbounded prosperity and champagne-induced gaiety, fell a good deal short of those marks for most American working people. Throughout the decade, unemployment rose, quietly, almost anonymously. It was a time of considerable hardship for many of the unemployed, long before the days of unemployment insurance or supplementary benefits.

The post world war I depression brought wages down sharply and caused major erosion of union membership-a loss of about a million members in the years from 1920 to 1923. The difficulties were multiplied by the decision of the National Association of Manufacturers and other antiunion “open shop” groups to wipe out or seriously diminish the status of American , can unions. The fear of “Bolsheviks,” often hysterical, that was nurtured by the Russian communist revolution was used gleefully by the antiunion forces. As early as 1913, President John Kirby of the NAM had decided the trade union movement was “an un-American, illegal and infamous conspiracy.” As the Senate Civil Liberties Committee, headed by Sen. Robert LaFollette Jr., reported years later, such demands as “union recognition, shorter hours, higher wages, regulation of child labor and the hours and wages of women and children in industry” came to be seen-under the influence of the NAM-sponsored ‘American Plan’ -as aspects of the alleged communist revolution from which the anti-labor employers wanted to save the nation. Strikebreaking, blacklisting and vigilanteeism became, for a time, acceptable aspects of this new and spurious brand of patriotism. The “yellow dog contract,” which workers had to sign in order to get a job, bound them never to join a union; at the same time, the corporations promoted employee representation plans or company unions-pale and generally useless imitations of the real thing.

In November 1935, John L. Lewis announced the creation of the CIO, the Committee for Industrial Organization, composed of about a dozen leaders of AFL unions, to carry on the effort for industrial unionism. Industrial Unions are unions that organize an entire industry regardless of skill. In short they where unions of unskilled workers. Lewis, born in Iowa in 1880 of Welsh immigrant parents, went to work in the coal mines and became president of the Mine Workers in 1920. An orator of remarkable virtuosity, Lewis voiced increasingly bitter attacks on his colleagues on the AFL Executive Council; his words helped speed the break. In 1936, the various CIO unions were expelled from the Federation. In 1938 the CIO held its first constitutional convention and became the Congress of Industrial Organizations.

In any event, the CIO began a remarkably successful series of organizing campaigns, and over the next few years, brought industrial unionism to large sectors of basic American industry. At the same time the unions remaining in the AFL registered even more substantial gains in membership. During World War 11, the AFL and CIO, while preserving areas of disagreement, began to find more substantial bases for working together on problems affecting all workers. In time many of the old antagonisms had died out and the old issues had been resolved. The stage was set for merger of the two labor groups. They were reunited into the AFL-CIO at a convention in New York opening on Dec. 5, 1955.

The AFL-CIO merger and its accompanying agreements brought about the virtual elimination of jurisdictional disputes between unions that had plagued the labor movement and alienated public sympathy in earlier years. The unions placed a new priority on organizing workers in areas, industries and plants where no effective system of labor representation yet existed. In many cases, it meant crossing the barriers of old thinking and tired methods to reach the employees of companies which for years had resisted unions.

For the past forty years there has been a steady decline in both union membership and influence. There are several reasons for such a decline, the first having to do with employers keeping their businesses union-free. Some were active in their opposition and even hired consultants to devise legal strategies to combat unions. Other employers put workers on the management team by appointing them to the board of directors or establishing profit-sharing plans to reward employees. The second reason for union decline is that new additions to the labor force have traditionally had little loyalty to organized labor. Because more and more women and teenagers are working and their incomes tend to be a family’s second income, they have a proclivity towards accepting lower wages, thus defeating the purpose of organized labor. The third and possibly the most important reason for the decline in unions is that they are victims of their own success. Unions raised their wages substantially above the wages paid to nonunion workers. Therefore, many union-made products have become so expensive that sales were lost to less expensive foreign competitors and nonunion producers. This resulted in companies having to cut back on production, which caused some workers to lose their jobs, and hence, unions some of their members. Also, the recent shift in this country towards technology and service has made our economy less reliant in the types of industrial jobs that tended to be union strongholds. Today’s worker tends to more highly educated and tends to the professional, white coller class. All of these have conspired to decrease union membership.


 

 

The Labor Union Movement in America - 2020 through 2023

The labor union movement in America has experienced a resurgence in recent years. After decades of decline, union membership has begun to increase, and workers are increasingly turning to unions to advocate for their rights and improve their working conditions.

This resurgence is due to a number of factors, including the COVID-19 pandemic, the Great Resignation, and a growing awareness of the benefits of unions. The pandemic exposed the many vulnerabilities of workers, and many realized that they needed a collective voice to fight for their safety and health. The Great Resignation gave workers more bargaining power, and many are using it to demand better wages, benefits, and working conditions. And as more and more workers see the benefits of unions, they are joining in record numbers.

In 2022, union membership increased by 200,000, the largest increase since 2014. And in 2023, union membership is on track to increase again. This growth is being driven by a number of factors, including:

  • The pandemic: The pandemic exposed the many vulnerabilities of workers, and many realized that they needed a collective voice to fight for their safety and health. Unions played a critical role in advocating for workers during the pandemic, and many workers saw firsthand the power of unions.
  • The Great Resignation: The Great Resignation gave workers more bargaining power, and many are using it to demand better wages, benefits, and working conditions. Unions are helping workers to negotiate better contracts and to improve their working conditions.
  • Growing awareness of the benefits of unions: More and more workers are becoming aware of the benefits of unions, including higher wages, better benefits, and safer working conditions. Unions are also playing a leading role in the fight for social and economic justice.

The resurgence of the labor union movement is having a positive impact on workers and on the economy. Unionized workers earn higher wages and have better benefits than non-unionized workers. Unions also help to reduce income inequality and to create a more just and equitable society.

Here are some specific examples of the labor union movement in action in America from 2020 through 2023:

  • Starbucks: In 2021, Starbucks workers began organizing unions across the country. By the end of 2022, over 200 Starbucks stores had voted to unionize. Starbucks workers are fighting for higher wages, better benefits, and more say in their working conditions.
  • Amazon: In 2021, Amazon workers in Bessemer, Alabama, voted on whether to form a union. The vote was narrowly defeated, but it was a historic moment for Amazon workers. In 2022, Amazon workers in Staten Island, New York, voted to form a union, the first Amazon warehouse in the United States to do so. Amazon workers are fighting for better wages, benefits, and working conditions.
  • Hollywood: In 2023, Hollywood was rocked by a rare double strike as writers hit the picket lines in May and actors joined them in July. The strikes ended in late September, as the Writers Guild of America and the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists agreed on new contracts with the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers. The strikes were successful in securing better wages, benefits, and working conditions for Hollywood workers.
  • Nurses: In 2023, nurses at several major hospitals across the country went on strike. Nurses are fighting for better wages, benefits, and staffing levels. The strikes have been successful in securing some gains, but nurses are continuing to fight for their rights.

The labor union movement in America is facing a number of challenges, including:

  • Anti-union laws: The United States has some of the weakest labor laws in the developed world. These laws make it difficult for workers to organize unions and to bargain collectively.
  • Employer opposition: Employers often fiercely oppose union organizing efforts. They use a variety of tactics to discourage workers from joining unions, including intimidation, threats, and firing.
  • Public misconception: There is a public misconception that unions are no longer necessary and that they are bad for the economy. This misconception is often perpetuated by employers and by the media.

Despite these challenges, the labor union movement in America is on the rise. Workers are increasingly realizing that unions are the best way to improve their working conditions and to create a more just and equitable society.

Here are some things that can be done to support the labor union movement:

  • Learn about unions: The more people know about unions, the more likely they are to support them. Learn about the history of the labor union movement, the benefits of unions, and the challenges.

  • Support unionized businesses: When you buy goods and services from unionized businesses, you are supporting workers and their families. You are also sending a message to employers that you value unions.

  • Donate to unions: Unions rely on donations to fund their organizing and bargaining efforts. You can donate to a specific union or to a general fund that supports unions across the country.

  • Volunteer with unions: Unions need volunteers to help with organizing, bargaining, and other activities. You can volunteer your time and skills to help unions achieve their goals.

  • Educate others about unions: Talk to your friends, family, and coworkers about the importance of unions. Share your knowledge about the benefits of unions and the challenges they face.

  • Contact your elected officials: Let your elected officials know that you support unions and that you want them to pass laws that protect workers’ rights to organize and bargain collectively.
  • The labor union movement is an important part of a healthy democracy. Unions help to ensure that workers have a voice in their workplaces and that they are treated fairly. By supporting the labor union movement, you can help to create a more just and equitable society.

    Here are some additional thoughts on the labor union movement in America from 2020 through 2023:

    • The labor union movement is becoming more diverse. Workers of color, women, and young workers are increasingly joining unions. This diversity is making the labor union movement stronger and more representative of the American workforce.
    • The labor union movement is focusing on a wider range of issues. In addition to fighting for better wages, benefits, and working conditions, unions are also fighting for social and economic justice. Unions are advocating for policies such as universal healthcare, paid family leave, and climate action.
    • The labor union movement is using new technologies to organize and communicate with workers. Unions are using social media, text messaging, and other digital tools to reach workers where they are.
    • The labor union movement in America is at a crossroads. Unions are facing a number of challenges, but they are also experiencing a resurgence. By supporting the labor union movement, you can help to create a more just and equitable society for all.

     

Frequently Asked Questions about the Labor Movement in America

A labor union is a group of workers who organize together to negotiate with their employer for better wages, benefits, and working conditions. Unions are governed by a constitution and bylaws, and they are typically led by elected officers.

Unions use a variety of tactics to achieve their goals, including collective bargaining, strikes, and boycotts. Collective bargaining is the process by which unions negotiate with employers on behalf of their members. Strikes are work stoppages that unions use to pressure employers to meet their demands. Boycotts are organized refusals to buy goods or services from a particular company.

Unions play an important role in the American economy. They help to ensure that workers are treated fairly and that they have a voice in their workplaces. Unions also help to reduce income inequality and to create a more just and equitable society.

There are many benefits to joining a union, including:

  • Higher wages: Unionized workers earn an average of 11% more than non-unionized workers.
  • Better benefits: Unionized workers are more likely to have health insurance, retirement savings plans, and other benefits.
  • Safer working conditions: Unions fight for safer working conditions and for better enforcement of safety regulations.
  • More job security: Unionized workers are less likely to be laid off than non-unionized workers.
  • A voice in the workplace: Unions give workers a collective voice in their workplaces and a say in decisions that affect their jobs.

In addition to these direct benefits, unions also play a broader role in society. Unions advocate for policies that benefit all workers, such as a higher minimum wage, paid family leave, and affordable healthcare. Unions also help to build a stronger democracy by giving workers a voice in the political process.

If you are interested in joining a union, the first step is to research the unions that represent workers in your industry or occupation. You can find information about unions online or by contacting your local AFL-CIO office.

Once you have identified a union that you are interested in joining, you can contact the union to learn more about their membership requirements and to start the process of joining.

The labor union movement in America is facing a number of challenges today, including:

  • Anti-union laws: The United States has some of the weakest labor laws in the developed world. These laws make it difficult for workers to organize unions and to bargain collectively.
  • Employer opposition: Employers often fiercely oppose union organizing efforts. They use a variety of tactics to discourage workers from joining unions, including intimidation, threats, and firing.
  • Public misconception: There is a public misconception that unions are no longer necessary and that they are bad for the economy. This misconception is often perpetuated by employers and by the media.

Despite these challenges, the labor union movement in America is on the rise. Workers are increasingly realizing that unions are the best way to improve their working conditions and to create a more just and equitable society.

There are many ways to support the labor union movement, including:

  • Learn about unions: The more people know about unions, the more likely they are to support them. Learn about the history of the labor union movement, the benefits of unions, and the challenges they face.
  • Support unionized businesses: When you buy goods and services from unionized businesses, you are supporting workers and their families. You are also sending a message to employers that you value unions.
  • Donate to unions: Unions rely on donations to fund their organizing and bargaining efforts. You can donate to a specific union or to a general fund that supports unions across the country.
  • Volunteer with unions: Unions need volunteers to help with organizing, bargaining, and other activities. You can volunteer your time and skills to help unions achieve their goals.
  • Educate others about unions: Talk to your friends, family, and coworkers about the importance of unions. Share your knowledge about the benefits of unions and the challenges they face.
  • Contact your elected officials: Let your elected officials know that you support unions and that you want them to pass laws that protect workers’ rights to organize and bargain collectively.

Public sector unions represent workers who are employed by the government, such as teachers, firefighters, and police officers. Private sector unions represent workers who are employed by private companies.

Public sector unions are subject to different laws and regulations than private sector unions. For example, public sector unions in some states are required to obtain permission from the government before they can strike.

Despite these differences, public sector unions and private sector unions share many of the same goals. They both fight for better wages, benefits, and working conditions for their members.

The future of the labor union movement in America is uncertain. On the one hand, unions are facing a number of challenges, such as anti-union laws, employer opposition, and public misconceptions.

On the other hand, there are a number of positive trends that suggest that the labor union movement is on the rise. Workers are increasingly realizing that unions are the best way to improve their working conditions and to create a more just and equitable society. Unions are also becoming more diverse and are focusing on a wider range of issues.

Overall, the future of the labor union movement in America depends on a number of factors, including the ability of unions to overcome the challenges they face and to adapt to the changing economy.

There have been a number of successful labor union campaigns in recent years. Here are a few examples:

  • In 2021, Starbucks workers began organizing unions across the country. By the end of 2022, over 200 Starbucks stores had voted to unionize. Starbucks workers are fighting for higher wages, better benefits, and more say in their working conditions.
  • In 2021, Amazon workers in Bessemer, Alabama, voted on whether to form a union. The vote was narrowly defeated, but it was a historic moment for Amazon workers. In 2022, Amazon workers in Staten Island, New York, voted to form a union, the first Amazon warehouse in the United States to do so. Amazon workers are fighting for better wages, benefits, and working conditions.
  • In 2023, Hollywood was rocked by a rare double strike as writers hit the picket lines in May and actors joined them in July. The strikes ended in late September, as the Writers Guild of America and the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists agreed on new contracts with the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers. The strikes were successful in securing better wages, benefits, and working conditions for Hollywood workers.
  • In 2023, nurses at several major hospitals across the country went on strike. Nurses are fighting for better wages, benefits, and staffing levels. The strikes have been successful in securing some gains, but nurses are continuing to fight for their rights.

These are just a few examples of the many successful labor union campaigns that have taken place in recent years. These campaigns demonstrate that workers are willing to stand up for their rights and that unions can be effective in achieving their goals.